When journaling becomes overthinking: how to stop the entry running away

Journaling is usually recommended as a cure for overthinking. For a lot of people it is. For some it becomes the opposite: a second venue for the same loop, with better sentences and a more respectable name.

If you finish writing more agitated than you started, that's worth taking seriously rather than pushing through.

How to tell which one you're doing

Useful writing moves. It goes from event to feeling to something you didn't know you thought. There's usually a sentence somewhere that surprises you.

Rumination circles. It restates the situation from a slightly different angle, again, in a slightly different order. Nothing new arrives, and the writing gets longer as it goes.

The test isn't length or subject. It's whether anything moved. Read back last week's entries and ask whether you learned anything or just described the same afternoon four times.

Set an end, not a length

Open-ended writing is the main way this goes wrong. If a page has no floor, an anxious mind will keep filling it.

Give it a stop. Ten minutes on a timer, or three specific questions and then done. The point isn't discipline for its own sake. It's that a container forces the writing to reach for something instead of continuing to circle.

Write forward, not sideways

Rumination lives in analysis of the past. Why did I say that, what did they mean, what does it say about me.

So change the question type. Instead of "why did this happen," write "what would I do if it happened again," or "what's the next actual step," or "what would I tell someone else in this position." Forward-facing questions have endings. Backward-facing ones often don't.

Finish with a decision line

This is the single most useful habit for overthinkers. However long the entry, the last line has to be one of three things: something I'm going to do, something I'm choosing to leave alone, or something I need more information about.

It forces a landing. And when you read back later, the entries have shape instead of dissolving into more of the same.

Start your own private journal tonight.

Innera keeps your stories encrypted on your device. Free to start.

Download on the App Store

Free to start. Your stories stay encrypted on your device.

Know when not to write

There are states where writing makes things worse. Very late at night. Mid panic attack. In the first hour of an argument. The writing is real, but the thinking underneath it isn't reliable enough to be worth recording as though it were.

It's fine to note three lines and stop. Some things need a walk, a night's sleep, or another person, not another page.

Prompts that tend to close rather than open

• What is actually in my control here?
• What's the next step, not the whole path?
• What would I tell a friend in this exact situation?
• What am I trying to decide, and what would make the decision easier?
• Is this something I'm doing, leaving alone, or waiting on?

Rereading, carefully

Overthinkers reread more than most people, and it can turn into another loop. A useful rule: reread in batches, weeks or months at a time, looking for patterns, rather than rereading yesterday's entry today.

Innera keeps every story encrypted on your device, which is what makes it safe to write the unfinished, unflattering, still-circling version at all. That version is where the useful sentence usually turns up, but only if nobody else is ever going to see it.